top of page
Search

ADHD Is Not a Superpower — And Calling It One Is Making Things Worse

  • Writer: Michelle Karth
    Michelle Karth
  • Jul 5
  • 8 min read

The Highlight Reel Nobody Asked For


I’m sure you’ve heard it: “Your ADHD is a superpower.”


I get the reframe. I really do.


But I always wonder...have those people ever sent a text at 2pm, heard nothing by 2:15, and checked their phone twelve times in the meantime?Have they ever spent the next hour constructing a full story about why there’s no response… only to get a reply that says, “Sorry, I was in a meeting. What’s up?”


Everything was fine. It was always fine.


Except I just spent two hours in emotional freefall over a late text.Chest tight. Hands shaky. Like I’d just survived something far more serious than silence.

And the hardest part? This isn’t a one-off. It happens all the time.


So when someone says,“That’s just your ADHD sensitivity. It makes you more empathetic. It’s basically a superpower…”what are you supposed to do with that?

Because here’s what the “superpower” narrative leaves out:


There’s nothing super about losing hours to obsessive spiraling over something that wasn’t even real.There’s nothing gifted about the way rejection—real or imagined—can hijack your entire nervous system in seconds.And there’s nothing empowering about organizing your life around avoiding a feeling that shows up anyway.


This isn’t a superpower.


This is Rejection Sensitive Dysphoria.


And glossing over it doesn’t help—it actually makes it harder to talk about what’s really happening.


Because when you label something a “gift,” you make it harder for people to admit when it’s hurting them.


And honestly? That framing—no matter how well-meaning—can do real harm.


We can respect neurodivergence without pretending it’s painless.

The Science: What ADHD Actually Is


ADHD is a neurodevelopmental condition that affects approximately 5–8% of children and around 2.5–4% of adults worldwide. It’s highly heritable, estimates suggest around 70–80%, placing it among the more strongly inherited psychiatric conditions.


This is not the result of poor discipline, bad parenting, or lack of effort. It reflects differences in how the brain develops and functions.


Neuroimaging research has consistently identified differences in brain networks involved in attention, executive function, and self-regulation, particularly in regions like the prefrontal cortex. These differences don’t mean the brain is “defective,” but they do mean it operates differently.


One system that appears to function differently in ADHD is the brain’s reward and motivation circuitry, which involves dopamine signaling. Rather than a simple “deficit,” current research suggests altered sensitivity to reward, especially when tasks are not immediately engaging, novel, or meaningful.


That’s why starting or sustaining effort on certain tasks can feel disproportionately difficult, even when the person genuinely wants to do them.


This isn’t a willpower issue.It’s a difference in how motivation is generated and maintained.


Where the Superpower Narrative Came From — And Why It Exploded


The superpower framing didn't appear out of nowhere. It emerged from a genuinely good impulse: to push back against decades of stigma, shame, and the devastating message that ADHD was simply a character flaw dressed up in clinical language.


And then social media happened.


During the pandemic, ADHD content exploded on TikTok and Instagram. A 2022 study in The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry found that 52% of the top 100 ADHD TikTok videos contained misleading information, with the vast majority of creators citing lived experience rather than clinical training. The superpower narrative thrived in this environment because it was shareable, feel-good, and offered a dopamine hit of validation to a community that had been starved of it.

Celebrities amplified it further. Paris Hilton wrote a 2024 Teen Vogue op-ed titled "Why ADHD Is My Superpower." Olympic swimmer Michael Phelps has spoken about reframing his ADHD as a gift. Channing Tatum. Ty Pennington. Justin Timberlake.


Here's the thing. These are some of the most privileged, supported, and resourced people on earth. They have personal assistants, creative directors, financial managers, and entire teams of people compensating for executive dysfunction on their behalf. Calling ADHD their superpower is a bit like calling a broken leg a running advantage because you won a race on crutches built by an expert team.


Two Very Different Experiences of the Same Narrative


To the Person Newly Discovering Their ADHD, It Feels Like:


Finally…a reframe. A way to hold my head up. A permission slip to stop hating myself for the executive dysfunction, the missed deadlines, the chaos, the shame spiral after every forgotten appointment. 


The superpower language arrives like a lifeline.


And for a moment, it helps. The validation is real. The relief is real.


But then Monday comes back. And Tuesday. And the job you almost lost comes back. And the relationship where you keep forgetting important dates and your partner has stopped believing your apologies…that comes back, too.


And the superpower narrative has nothing to say about any of that. Because it was never designed to live in the hard days. It was designed for the highlight reel.


To the Person Who Has Been Living This For Decades, It Feels Like:


Dismissal. A shiny, well-intentioned form of "just think positive." The same energy, just with better branding.


A 2025 study published in Scientific Reports examined the lived experiences of 28 women with late-diagnosed ADHD. What they found was stark. Participants reported decades of criticism and lack of support from both society and medical professionals. They described internalizing that criticism so completely that it became indistinguishable from their own voice. Guilt. Shame. Disconcertingly low self-esteem. Lives spent apologizing for a nervous system nobody ever properly explained to them.


Not one of them described their ADHD as a superpower.


The Real Cost of Getting This Wrong


It Delays Diagnosis — Especially for Women


The superpower framing is particularly dangerous for women and girls, who are already a systematically underserved population in ADHD research and clinical practice.


A 2024 Swedish population study of 85,330 people found that women receive their ADHD diagnosis at an average age of 23.5, compared to 19.6 for men. And those are the averages…many women aren't diagnosed until their 30s, 40s, or 50s, often after a string of antidepressants that never worked because they were never depressed in the first place. They had ADHD.


Girls with ADHD typically display more inattentive symptoms rather than hyperactive behaviors, leading to mischaracterization as simply shy, lazy, or anxious. 


When we dress ADHD up as a superpower, we make it harder to recognize what it actually looks like in the people it most frequently hides in. A woman who is high-functioning, high-achieving, and completely falling apart internally doesn’t look like TikTok superpower content. She looks like she's managing fine. She's not.


It Breeds a Specific Kind of Shame


If ADHD is a superpower, then struggling with ADHD means you're failing to use your superpower correctly.


The pressure to see ADHD as purely positive can make people feel guilty about struggling, or ashamed when they need extra support. 


When the dominant cultural narrative says "ADHD is a gift," the person who is drowning in their ADHD doesn't conclude that the narrative is wrong. They conclude that they’re broken in a way that goes beyond even their diagnosis. 


Where This Becomes a Problem


1. It can obscure recognition—especially in women


ADHD in girls and women is often underrecognized. Many present with inattentive symptoms rather than hyperactivity, and are more likely to be described as anxious, disorganized, or overwhelmed rather than evaluated for ADHD.


As a result, diagnosis often happens later—sometimes decades later.


When ADHD is portrayed primarily as a “strength,” it can become even harder to identify in people who are struggling quietly. 


2. It can create a subtle form of shame


If ADHD is framed as a gift, then struggling with it can feel like a personal failure.

Instead of questioning the narrative, people may question themselves:

Why can’t I make this work if it’s supposed to be an advantage?


That gap between expectation and lived experience can deepen feelings of inadequacy.


3. It can complicate conversations about support

Framing ADHD as entirely positive can make it harder to advocate for accommodations, treatment, or structural support.


In reality, many people with ADHD benefit from:

  • external structure and accountability

  • reduced cognitive load environments

  • medication, where appropriate

  • clinicians who understand neurodivergence


These supports aren’t contradictions to strength. They’re responses to real needs.


A More Useful Way to Think About It


Some people with ADHD do experience traits—like creativity, hyperfocus in specific contexts, or big-picture thinking—that can be valuable.


But those traits are not the same as the condition itself.


ADHD includes:

  • executive function challenges

  • difficulty with task initiation

  • emotional dysregulation

  • variability in attention and energy


It’s possible to acknowledge both:

  • the strengths that can coexist

  • and the challenges that require support


Without collapsing one into the other.


The Tools: What We Should Be Saying Instead


1. Name It Honestly — All of It


ADHD has real costs and real challenges. Naming them is not self-pity. It's accurate. And accuracy is the foundation of actually getting help. You cannot seek support for something you've been taught to reframe as a strength.


The goal is not toxic positivity. The goal is honest self-knowledge, and understanding your nervous system clearly enough to build a life that actually works for it. Rather than one that pretends the challenges aren't there.


2. Separate Traits From the Condition


This is the nuance the superpower narrative collapses. Some people with ADHD do experience traits (creativity, hyperfocus, pattern recognition, big-picture thinking) that genuinely serve them in specific contexts. Those traits are real. But they aren’t ADHD. They’re traits that happen to coexist with ADHD in some people, in some contexts, under some conditions.


You can celebrate a trait without romanticizing the condition that came with it. The prefrontal cortex differences. The dopamine dysregulation. The executive dysfunction. The emotional dysregulation. The exhaustion of a nervous system that never gets to rest. 


3. Build Support Structures — Real Ones


Body doubling. Medication, if appropriate and accessible. External accountability systems. Environments with reduced sensory demand. Therapists who understand neurodivergence. Employers who offer genuine accommodations. These are not workarounds for a superpower. They’re necessary scaffolding for a nervous system that operates differently, and deserves support rather than a motivational poster.


4. Find the Language That Actually Fits


Not superpower. Not broken. Something more honest and more useful: different, with real costs and real strengths, deserving of real understanding.

That framing doesn't make a shareable TikTok. But it makes a life that's actually livable.


You Deserve More Than a Highlight Reel


Here's what I want to say to you directly.


Your struggles aren’t a failure to activate your superpower. They’re the predictable result of a nervous system that processes the world differently, in a world that was not built for your brain and has not adequately supported you.

You’re allowed to be tired. You’re allowed to find this hard. You’re allowed to want more than a reframe to want actual support, actual understanding, and an actual diagnosis from someone who sees the full picture.


The superpower narrative was trying to give you dignity. What you deserve is something better than dignity as a consolation prize. You deserve to be seen accurately, supported practically, and understood completely.


If you've been wondering whether what you're experiencing might be ADHD, or if you've been diagnosed and are still struggling to understand your own nervous system, our team at the Adult Autism Assessment Center is here. You can start with some of our free screeners as a first step. The Adult ADHD Self-Report Scale (ASRS-V1.1) and the Structured Adult ADHD Self-Test (SAAST). 


You can also book a free consultation with one of our therapists. We specialize in seeing the whole picture, not just the highlight reel. 


And if you're tired of being mistranslated, our team of neurodiversity-affirming clinicians at the Adult Autism Assessment Center would love to meet you, the real, warm, deeply-feeling you. You can book a free consultation with any of us anytime.


Our clinic She Rocks The Spectrum is centered around women and girls, while our clinic Therapy 4 Autistic Men is focused on men and boys.


Warmly,


Michelle Karth, PhD, PhD Behavioral Neuroscience 

Autism Advocate 










References


Faraone, S. V., Banaschewski, T., Coghill, D., Zheng, Y., Biederman, J., Bellgrove, M. A., et al. (2021). The World Federation of ADHD International Consensus Statement: 208 evidence-based conclusions about the disorder. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 128, 789–818. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2021.01.022


Holden, E., & Kobayashi-Wood, H. (2025). Adverse experiences of women with undiagnosed ADHD and the invaluable role of diagnosis. Scientific Reports, 15, 20945. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-04782-y


Martínez, A., et al. (2026). Ranking lived barriers to ADHD diagnosis in adult women. Psychology of Woman Journal, 7(1), 1–12. https://journals.kmanpub.com/index.php/psywoman/article/download/5050/9084/28060



Yeung, A., Ng, E., & Abi-Jaoude, E. (2022). TikTok and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder: A cross-sectional study of social media content quality. The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 67(12), 899–906. https://doi.org/10.1177/07067437221082854

 
 
 
bottom of page